Tuesday, March 10, 2015
Tuesday, February 10, 2015
Tuesday, November 4, 2014
Monday, September 22, 2014
Saturday, July 19, 2014
Paranormal Activity - How Para 102 is a hidden gem in Jaitley's budget
Majority of people missed a very important piece of announcement on the budget day. Even I did not think about it till I decided to read the full budget transcript this Friday evening – yeah, that’s how I spend my Friday nights.
I found a hidden gem in the orgy of information and announcement in the para 102 – just where the discussion about MSME sector starts. Here is the snapshot:
And now why this para is important. Before I start torturing my keyboard, here is a snapshot from India Market Strategy Report from Credit Suisse published in July 2013 – exactly a year ago.
The report cites and analyses National Statistics Commission data and reckon that Half of India’s GDP and a whopping 90% of its employment is generated in informal sector. The report also mentions that “Unlike in the developed economies where informality is purely a deliberate choice to avoid taxation or regulations, in India it is more structural: a reflection of the lack of development and limited government reach.”
This does not mean that GDP of India is underestimated by 50%. Nah. GDP of any country is anyway an estimated number – but this estimate is particularly doubtful and is bound to get revised, hopefully upwards, if 50% is outside the reach of government surveyors. Government conducts surveys, updates its methodologies and its GDP calculation series every few years. Last time it was done GDP calculation jumped by 0.6% annualized for all years in the series. See the chart below.
This data has implications for taxpayers also. It is a well-known fact that India is one of the most taxed countries in the world. And it is by definition, informal sector is outside the purview of tax authorities. So the formal part of the economy gets taxed heavily.
What Arun Jaitley has tried to do in his maiden budget is sort of recognize the contribution made by the informal sector – Own account enterprises and decided to set up a committee to study ways to reach, cover, finance and then maybe tax them.
When countries around the globe are busy finding ways to generate income from erstwhile illegal activities – for example, sale of marijuana in some US states (read here, here and here), India already has all the money on the table but not in the record books.
If India is able to make some significant progress in this area, not only India will have higher reported GDP, better employment records but also better insurance and banking penetrations, more people under social security net and in the meanwhile tax net will increase and will bring more equity to the taxpayers around the country.
Wonder, where is the debate over this?
I found a hidden gem in the orgy of information and announcement in the para 102 – just where the discussion about MSME sector starts. Here is the snapshot:
And now why this para is important. Before I start torturing my keyboard, here is a snapshot from India Market Strategy Report from Credit Suisse published in July 2013 – exactly a year ago.
The report cites and analyses National Statistics Commission data and reckon that Half of India’s GDP and a whopping 90% of its employment is generated in informal sector. The report also mentions that “Unlike in the developed economies where informality is purely a deliberate choice to avoid taxation or regulations, in India it is more structural: a reflection of the lack of development and limited government reach.”
This does not mean that GDP of India is underestimated by 50%. Nah. GDP of any country is anyway an estimated number – but this estimate is particularly doubtful and is bound to get revised, hopefully upwards, if 50% is outside the reach of government surveyors. Government conducts surveys, updates its methodologies and its GDP calculation series every few years. Last time it was done GDP calculation jumped by 0.6% annualized for all years in the series. See the chart below.
This data has implications for taxpayers also. It is a well-known fact that India is one of the most taxed countries in the world. And it is by definition, informal sector is outside the purview of tax authorities. So the formal part of the economy gets taxed heavily.
What Arun Jaitley has tried to do in his maiden budget is sort of recognize the contribution made by the informal sector – Own account enterprises and decided to set up a committee to study ways to reach, cover, finance and then maybe tax them.
When countries around the globe are busy finding ways to generate income from erstwhile illegal activities – for example, sale of marijuana in some US states (read here, here and here), India already has all the money on the table but not in the record books.
If India is able to make some significant progress in this area, not only India will have higher reported GDP, better employment records but also better insurance and banking penetrations, more people under social security net and in the meanwhile tax net will increase and will bring more equity to the taxpayers around the country.
Wonder, where is the debate over this?
Friday, July 11, 2014
Budget 2014 - Economy before Markets
Arun Jaitley presented his maiden budget on Thursday. The expectations from the budget were running high since the Modi govt got elected to power with clear majority. Narendra Modi's election campaign was rife with promises of reforms, employment and better days ahead. This budget, along with the railway budget presented on Tuesday were closely watched as they signaled the real intentions of new govt in power. It was not just investor's but the general public's way of finding out whether Modi govt can walk the talk.
Arun Jaitley, in a limited time and little maneuvering room available to him did a good job. He presented a budget which clearly indicated that India meant business. He, through his policy announcements tried to build a strong foundation for pro-growth path ahead. He did not fell in the trap of announcing reform measures to make stock market investors happy. Rather, he kept the focus on the audacious task of bringing economy house in order now, so that the benefits of growth can be reaped by all later.
But this budget was also not without few misses and disappointments. Many investors expected some announcement of doing away with controversial tax laws which FM has deliberately chose not to address. He explained his reasoning here in this interview. He also did not mention any policy to strengthen the recovery mechanism for banks.
Most investors were keen to find out how FM will create a balance between fiscal consolidation and kickstart the growth cycle. FM bravely accepted the challenge of capping the fiscal deficit target at ambitious 4.1% set by his predecessor. The fact that markets would not have blamed him or his govt on seeing a higher target number clearly sets out the intentions of the new govt. How much success will he meet only time will tell. For now, we can see and check the math behind the numbers and see for ourselves how much of these targets are achievable.
To meet the fiscal deficits target, FM seems to rely heavily on aggressive tax collections targets and divestment proceeds. The tax revenue is assumed to grow by 19.8% over actual FY14 figures with nominal GDP growth estimate of 13.4%. This tax revenue target is difficult to achieve, if not entirely impossible. The implicit assumption of tax elasticity of 1.5 in the tax revenue target is more reasonable during boom times, not when economy is trying to get out of pits.
Also, a third of tax revenues is corporate taxes which depend on their profitability, something which is beyond govt control. It will be unfortunate if govt resort to tax terrorism like its predecessor. In the event of not meeting their targets, they may have to hike their divestment targets.
Speaking of divestment targets, govt is hoping to net Rs. 63,425 crores in proceeds. Private companies have raised Rs. 12,000 crores via QIPs (which were heavily oversubscribed) in last few months. With India receiving $20bn annual FII inflows, the divestment target does not look unreasonable. Most analysts/economists expects govt to put its stake in Coal India and ONGC on block for retail investors soon. This will not only help achieve divestment targets, they will also help govt to adhere to SEBI prescribed promotor stake limit.
All in all, I think govt is on right track prioritizing fiscal consolidation over pro-growth measures. It would have been easy for govt to get carried away as country struggles with low growth rates, high inflation and threats of weak monsoons and drought situations. Instead, FM focused on getting the house in order, tightening the belts while trying not to hurt the wallet of general public and preparing the ground for better days ahead.
Arun Jaitley, in a limited time and little maneuvering room available to him did a good job. He presented a budget which clearly indicated that India meant business. He, through his policy announcements tried to build a strong foundation for pro-growth path ahead. He did not fell in the trap of announcing reform measures to make stock market investors happy. Rather, he kept the focus on the audacious task of bringing economy house in order now, so that the benefits of growth can be reaped by all later.
But this budget was also not without few misses and disappointments. Many investors expected some announcement of doing away with controversial tax laws which FM has deliberately chose not to address. He explained his reasoning here in this interview. He also did not mention any policy to strengthen the recovery mechanism for banks.
Most investors were keen to find out how FM will create a balance between fiscal consolidation and kickstart the growth cycle. FM bravely accepted the challenge of capping the fiscal deficit target at ambitious 4.1% set by his predecessor. The fact that markets would not have blamed him or his govt on seeing a higher target number clearly sets out the intentions of the new govt. How much success will he meet only time will tell. For now, we can see and check the math behind the numbers and see for ourselves how much of these targets are achievable.
To meet the fiscal deficits target, FM seems to rely heavily on aggressive tax collections targets and divestment proceeds. The tax revenue is assumed to grow by 19.8% over actual FY14 figures with nominal GDP growth estimate of 13.4%. This tax revenue target is difficult to achieve, if not entirely impossible. The implicit assumption of tax elasticity of 1.5 in the tax revenue target is more reasonable during boom times, not when economy is trying to get out of pits.
Also, a third of tax revenues is corporate taxes which depend on their profitability, something which is beyond govt control. It will be unfortunate if govt resort to tax terrorism like its predecessor. In the event of not meeting their targets, they may have to hike their divestment targets.
Speaking of divestment targets, govt is hoping to net Rs. 63,425 crores in proceeds. Private companies have raised Rs. 12,000 crores via QIPs (which were heavily oversubscribed) in last few months. With India receiving $20bn annual FII inflows, the divestment target does not look unreasonable. Most analysts/economists expects govt to put its stake in Coal India and ONGC on block for retail investors soon. This will not only help achieve divestment targets, they will also help govt to adhere to SEBI prescribed promotor stake limit.
All in all, I think govt is on right track prioritizing fiscal consolidation over pro-growth measures. It would have been easy for govt to get carried away as country struggles with low growth rates, high inflation and threats of weak monsoons and drought situations. Instead, FM focused on getting the house in order, tightening the belts while trying not to hurt the wallet of general public and preparing the ground for better days ahead.
Sunday, June 1, 2014
Weekly Market Commentary - May 26, 2014 - May 30, 2014
Elections are over. New govt is in place. The country is in midst of (sort of) growth crisis. Time has come for govt to roll up its sleeve.
Asia’s third largest economy grew 4.7% in FY14 vs. estimated 4.9% - second quarter of sub 5% growth. It is estimated that projects worth $105.1bn were shelved last year due to bureaucratic gridlock - highest in the past 18 years. Stressed loans in India amounted to $100bn or about 10% of all loans when debt-equity ratio of Indian firms has hit a two-decade high of 97.9%, according to Nomura.
Add to the mix, slowing global economy that is hemming in the country's exports growth and prospects of bleak monsoon, which might fire up the inflation fury. All these would lead to central bank staying hawkish on interest rates.
Sensex ended this week down by 1.9% while Nifty was down by 1.9% and Midcap down by 3.0%
Monday - Sensex up by 0.1%, Nifty down by 0.1%, Midcap down by 2.0%
Investors booked profits as BSE Sensex and CNX Nifty, two key benchmark indices loses steam. Midcaps declined by 2% after gaining more than 10% previous week. Recovery hopes from Modi govt have kept markets at elevated levels in recent weeks. Sun Pharma and Ranbaxy gained after court lifted a temporary stay on their merger.
Tuesday - Sensex down by 0.7%, Nifty down by 0.6%, Midcap down by 1.0%
Markets continue to tumble as investors continued to book some profits and turned cautious as they wait for new policies to be announced and implemented from PMO. Newly appointed finance minister Arun Jaitley assured investors of stable policy environment.
Wednesday - Sensex flat, Nifty up by 0.2%, Midcap up by 0.6%
Sensex ended the day flat while Nifty went up slightly as some value buying occurred on bourses after recent correction. Shipping corp surged 14% after company reported first net profit after Sept 2012 quarter as bulk shipping and liner businesses improved. ICRA also jumped 18% after Moody’s raised offer price to Rs. 2,400/share from Rs. 2, 000/share.
Thursday - Sensex down by 1.3%, Nifty down by 1.3%, Midcap down by 0.9%
Sensex and Nifty posted their biggest decline in nearly four months on the day of derivative expiry. This goes on to indicate that Modi euphoria might be showing sign of ebbing and investors will focus on actual deliverance now. Losses in blue chips were led by Infosys, which fell by 8% after it saw exit of another top management official from the company.
Friday - Sensex down by 0.1%, Nifty down by 0.1%, Midcap up by 0.3%
Investors continued to stay low as election rally loses momentum. Sensex and Nifty ended the week in red marking the first weekly fall over last one month.
Asia’s third largest economy grew 4.7% in FY14 vs. estimated 4.9% - second quarter of sub 5% growth. It is estimated that projects worth $105.1bn were shelved last year due to bureaucratic gridlock - highest in the past 18 years. Stressed loans in India amounted to $100bn or about 10% of all loans when debt-equity ratio of Indian firms has hit a two-decade high of 97.9%, according to Nomura.
Add to the mix, slowing global economy that is hemming in the country's exports growth and prospects of bleak monsoon, which might fire up the inflation fury. All these would lead to central bank staying hawkish on interest rates.
Sensex ended this week down by 1.9% while Nifty was down by 1.9% and Midcap down by 3.0%
Monday - Sensex up by 0.1%, Nifty down by 0.1%, Midcap down by 2.0%
Investors booked profits as BSE Sensex and CNX Nifty, two key benchmark indices loses steam. Midcaps declined by 2% after gaining more than 10% previous week. Recovery hopes from Modi govt have kept markets at elevated levels in recent weeks. Sun Pharma and Ranbaxy gained after court lifted a temporary stay on their merger.
Tuesday - Sensex down by 0.7%, Nifty down by 0.6%, Midcap down by 1.0%
Markets continue to tumble as investors continued to book some profits and turned cautious as they wait for new policies to be announced and implemented from PMO. Newly appointed finance minister Arun Jaitley assured investors of stable policy environment.
Wednesday - Sensex flat, Nifty up by 0.2%, Midcap up by 0.6%
Sensex ended the day flat while Nifty went up slightly as some value buying occurred on bourses after recent correction. Shipping corp surged 14% after company reported first net profit after Sept 2012 quarter as bulk shipping and liner businesses improved. ICRA also jumped 18% after Moody’s raised offer price to Rs. 2,400/share from Rs. 2, 000/share.
Thursday - Sensex down by 1.3%, Nifty down by 1.3%, Midcap down by 0.9%
Sensex and Nifty posted their biggest decline in nearly four months on the day of derivative expiry. This goes on to indicate that Modi euphoria might be showing sign of ebbing and investors will focus on actual deliverance now. Losses in blue chips were led by Infosys, which fell by 8% after it saw exit of another top management official from the company.
Friday - Sensex down by 0.1%, Nifty down by 0.1%, Midcap up by 0.3%
Investors continued to stay low as election rally loses momentum. Sensex and Nifty ended the week in red marking the first weekly fall over last one month.
Saturday, March 8, 2014
Weekly Market Commentary - Mar 3, 2014 - Mar 7, 2014
Both Sensex and Nifty ended this week at record all time highs. Investors, both domestic and foreign, are rushing in Indian markets to position themselves to benefit from an expected favorable election outcome. As I mentioned in my previous post, that favorable outcome is formation of stable NDA govt at the centre. With Congress losing its fight to retain prominence and AAP continues to use reality TV gimmicks to attract voters, NDA stock continues to rise.
As far as economics is concerned -- With India outperforming most of its emerging market peers in Feb, inflation declining, deficit numbers at four-year low and GDP growth bottoming out, India is definitely at a sweet spot.
Markets are expected to remain volatile in near term, as some people will book profits as markets rise while others will position themselves to benefit in a pre-election rally.
Sensex ended this week up 3.8%, Nifty was up by 4.0% while CNX Midcap was up by 4.1%.
Monday - Sensex down by 0.8%, Nifty down by 0.9%, Midcap down by 0.4%
War mongering in Ukraine sent investors’ mood around the world rolling down. World leaders unite in censuring the Russia’s move to send the forces in Crimea. Gold went up as fear and uncertainty rose. Indian markets ignored the improvement in HSBC PMI index – 52.5 in Feb vs. 51.4 in Jan, which indicated strongest manufacturing growth in last 12 months.
Tuesday - Sensex up by 1.3%, Nifty up by 1.2%, Midcap up by 1.3%
Benchmark indices bounced to their five-week highs as Russian President called back its troops back to their bases. Almost all sectoral indices ended up in green with cyclical leading the rally.
Wednesday - Sensex up by 0.3%, Nifty up by 0.5%, Midcap up by 1.4%
Markets continued their upward momentum. The benchmark Sensex closed just around 100 points away from its previous all time high. Investors have turned bullish ahead of general elections and have largely ignored the weakness in European markets.
Thursday - Sensex up by 1.1%, Nifty up by 1.1%, Midcap up by 1.4%
Benchmark indices soared past their earlier peak and set new record highs on the back of strong bullish investor sentiment as current account deficit numbers came at four-year low. With December CAD at 0.9% of GDP, exports picking up and gold imports subdued market is hopeful that the rupee will get a boost and FII inflows will increase.
Friday - Sensex up by 1.9%, Nifty up by 2.0%, Midcap up by 0.4%
Markets extended their winning streak and ended the week with all time record highs on the back of lower CAD numbers and increased fund flows from both domestic and foreign investors. Almost all indices ended the week in green barring IT and healthcare as investors churn their portfolios from export driven to domestic cyclical stories.
As far as economics is concerned -- With India outperforming most of its emerging market peers in Feb, inflation declining, deficit numbers at four-year low and GDP growth bottoming out, India is definitely at a sweet spot.
Markets are expected to remain volatile in near term, as some people will book profits as markets rise while others will position themselves to benefit in a pre-election rally.
Sensex ended this week up 3.8%, Nifty was up by 4.0% while CNX Midcap was up by 4.1%.
Monday - Sensex down by 0.8%, Nifty down by 0.9%, Midcap down by 0.4%
War mongering in Ukraine sent investors’ mood around the world rolling down. World leaders unite in censuring the Russia’s move to send the forces in Crimea. Gold went up as fear and uncertainty rose. Indian markets ignored the improvement in HSBC PMI index – 52.5 in Feb vs. 51.4 in Jan, which indicated strongest manufacturing growth in last 12 months.
Tuesday - Sensex up by 1.3%, Nifty up by 1.2%, Midcap up by 1.3%
Benchmark indices bounced to their five-week highs as Russian President called back its troops back to their bases. Almost all sectoral indices ended up in green with cyclical leading the rally.
Wednesday - Sensex up by 0.3%, Nifty up by 0.5%, Midcap up by 1.4%
Markets continued their upward momentum. The benchmark Sensex closed just around 100 points away from its previous all time high. Investors have turned bullish ahead of general elections and have largely ignored the weakness in European markets.
Thursday - Sensex up by 1.1%, Nifty up by 1.1%, Midcap up by 1.4%
Benchmark indices soared past their earlier peak and set new record highs on the back of strong bullish investor sentiment as current account deficit numbers came at four-year low. With December CAD at 0.9% of GDP, exports picking up and gold imports subdued market is hopeful that the rupee will get a boost and FII inflows will increase.
Friday - Sensex up by 1.9%, Nifty up by 2.0%, Midcap up by 0.4%
Markets extended their winning streak and ended the week with all time record highs on the back of lower CAD numbers and increased fund flows from both domestic and foreign investors. Almost all indices ended the week in green barring IT and healthcare as investors churn their portfolios from export driven to domestic cyclical stories.
Saturday, March 1, 2014
Weekly Market Commentary - Feb 24, 2014 - Feb 28, 2014
If one goes by the direction of the market, it seems that nation (investor populace mostly) has already made up its mind regarding the outcome of Lok Sabha elections. Continuous upward momentum indicates the increasing expectations of a stable NDA government in the centre. NDA govt is widely expected to undo the decade of policy paralysis and junking of pro-growth model of development and replace it with one with more pro-market flavor.
Sensex ended this week up 2.0%, Nifty was up by 1.4% while CNX Midcap was up by 1.8%.
Monday - Sensex up by 0.5%, Nifty up by 0.9%, Midcap up by 0.4%
Markets continued to move up as buying interest emerged in capital goods and banking sector stocks on the back of favorable policy measures and reduced deficit numbers announcements by outgoing UPA govt.
Tuesday - Sensex up by 0.2%, Nifty up by 0.4%, Midcap up by 0.1%
Benchmark indices were able to hold ground after a volatile session as F&O contracts near their expiry on coming Wednesday. The optimism about US recovery led to higher closing of IT stocks.
Wednesday - Sensex up by 0.6%, Nifty down by 1.0%, Midcap up by 0.2%
Sensex regained 21,000 mark as foreign funds continued to flow in Indian equities. Stocks also gained as traders due to short covering on F&O expiry day.
Thursday – Exchanges closed on Maha Shivratri
Friday - Sensex up by 0.6%, Nifty up by 1.1%, Midcap up by 1.2%
Markets closed higher ahead of GDP data release for quarter ending December. A Bloomberg poll showed the growth expectations to be 4.7% as against 4.8% in September quarter. Mood was also positive as Fed Chairperson Janet Yellen indicated that Fed would continue its tapering program in a measured way.
Sensex ended this week up 2.0%, Nifty was up by 1.4% while CNX Midcap was up by 1.8%.
Monday - Sensex up by 0.5%, Nifty up by 0.9%, Midcap up by 0.4%
Markets continued to move up as buying interest emerged in capital goods and banking sector stocks on the back of favorable policy measures and reduced deficit numbers announcements by outgoing UPA govt.
Tuesday - Sensex up by 0.2%, Nifty up by 0.4%, Midcap up by 0.1%
Benchmark indices were able to hold ground after a volatile session as F&O contracts near their expiry on coming Wednesday. The optimism about US recovery led to higher closing of IT stocks.
Wednesday - Sensex up by 0.6%, Nifty down by 1.0%, Midcap up by 0.2%
Sensex regained 21,000 mark as foreign funds continued to flow in Indian equities. Stocks also gained as traders due to short covering on F&O expiry day.
Thursday – Exchanges closed on Maha Shivratri
Friday - Sensex up by 0.6%, Nifty up by 1.1%, Midcap up by 1.2%
Markets closed higher ahead of GDP data release for quarter ending December. A Bloomberg poll showed the growth expectations to be 4.7% as against 4.8% in September quarter. Mood was also positive as Fed Chairperson Janet Yellen indicated that Fed would continue its tapering program in a measured way.
Friday, December 20, 2013
Summary of RBI-Analyst Conference Call - Dec 18, 2013
Dr. Raghuram Rajan (RRR): Recent readings suggest that headline inflation, both retail and wholesale, have increased mainly, but not exclusively on account of food prices. There is, however, reason to wait before determining the course of monetary policy. There are indications that vegetable prices may be turning down sharply. RBI has decided to maintain the status quo.
Reserve Bank will be vigilant and will act if expected softening of food inflation does not materialize and it does not translate into a significant reduction in headline inflation in the next round of data releases, or if inflation excluding food and fuel does not fall.
Gautam Rajesh Kumar, Trust Financial Consultancy: Given the fact that stability in Forex market has returned, CAD has come down, liquidity in the banking system is relatively comfortable, what is the comfort level of inflation for RBI to act on policy rate?
RRR: At this point trying to specify a final target is probably premature, but we do want to see both headline and core inflation come down. So we are also interested in seeing headline inflation which includes the food and fuel component also stabilise and fall.
Srinivasa Varadarajan, Mount Nathan Capital Management: In 1QCY14, it is estimated that about $15 billion of the oil swap will mature and will increase the rupee liquidity in the system. Will the period be used to actually push through the government debt swap at that point in time.
RRR: Actually the net amount is less than $7 billion right now. So that is approximately what will have to be repaid overtime. As and when the time comes, we will take a view as to how that repayment happens and it could be settled through an exchange of rupee funds based on the settlement amount. It could also be, the swaps could be rolled over if necessary and of course if market conditions permit, it can also be repaid.
Namrata Narkar, IDBI Bank: WPI inflation forecast is being placed largely between 6% and 7% for March 2014. How much of deviation from this forecast is tolerable and if the deviation is above the tolerable level, would the composition of such a deviation then hold significant?
RRR: It depends on not just the WPI, but a whole set of other measures. On the WPI we have been very clear on bringing headline below 5 and core below 3.
Prasanna, ICICI Securities: You have mentioned the negative output gap as a key factor in helping to contain inflation. Does that mean you do not expect the output gap to narrow in coming quarters and therefore you expect FY15 growth to remain around levels observed in H1FY14?
RRR: My personal sense is that with growth at let us say around 5%, we have somewhere between 1.5%-2% output gap at this point. So with that kind of situation, I think it will take a year or two to get back to potential and therefore we have some room or some time in which the output gap will continue to be negative and exert downward pressure on inflation.
Badri Niwas, Citi Bank: Given you have the experience of July, would you give some guidance to the market on whether the RBI will again use monetary policy tools as a defence for the currency in event of disruption risk that you mentioned manifesting?
RRR: There are some people who argue the disruption this time will be more limited, partly because people have already reacted somewhat over the last 3-4 months. And from India’s perspective, we are in a better position because a) our CAD is much more contained, b) our reserves have grown and we have shown an ability to raise funding if necessary and c) We have lost a fair amount in short maturity bond funds which have the ability to leave more quickly and what remains are the longer term funds.
Anjali Verma, PhillipCapital: RBI is in favour of removing gold import restrictions. Is it the right time to the remove restrictions and what adverse impact it can have on CAD.
RRR: Gold restrictions are distortion and they are a necessary distortion at this point to restore balance to the CAD. But going forward we would not like this distortion to persist and we would like to remove it.
Ashish Kela, Birla Sun Life Asset Management: Dr. Rajan had highlighted the need to provide real returns to savers. What is the plan on this front? Will this play a role in the monetary policy?
RRR: The question of providing real returns to savers is very much on our minds. We do want to restore savings growth and move towards financial savings by households and I think we have to bring inflation down to make sure that these returns are positive. In the meantime there are stop gap arrangements that are part of a longer term strategy. One example of that is inflation indexed bonds in which real returns are fixed at1.5%.
Rajeev Malik, CLSA: Given widespread macro level demand supply imbalances, what is the efficacy of a blunt instrument such as interest rate in loading CPI core inflation in the supply constrained economy?
RRR: Some of the areas where we had high inflation- pulses and milk- some of that inflation has come down considerably which means there is a supply response that is kicking in and higher prices are a way to activate that supply response. More generally, even in a situation where there are supply constraints of one kind or the other, to the extent that demand exceeds supply, it creates inflationary pressures, some of it is a necessary price adjustment or relative price adjustment, but some of it feeds into more widespread wage inflation.
Aastha Gudwani, Birla Sun Life: Are we done with the rollback of exceptional measures taken in July, is the cap on LAF here to stay? If yes, then how do you intend to reinstate repo as the permanent operative rate?
RRR: We have ample liquidity and we are largely, with a little bit of volatility, near about the repo rate as being the operational rate. So in that sense I think we have gone back to normal monetary policy at this point.
Reserve Bank will be vigilant and will act if expected softening of food inflation does not materialize and it does not translate into a significant reduction in headline inflation in the next round of data releases, or if inflation excluding food and fuel does not fall.
Gautam Rajesh Kumar, Trust Financial Consultancy: Given the fact that stability in Forex market has returned, CAD has come down, liquidity in the banking system is relatively comfortable, what is the comfort level of inflation for RBI to act on policy rate?
RRR: At this point trying to specify a final target is probably premature, but we do want to see both headline and core inflation come down. So we are also interested in seeing headline inflation which includes the food and fuel component also stabilise and fall.
Srinivasa Varadarajan, Mount Nathan Capital Management: In 1QCY14, it is estimated that about $15 billion of the oil swap will mature and will increase the rupee liquidity in the system. Will the period be used to actually push through the government debt swap at that point in time.
RRR: Actually the net amount is less than $7 billion right now. So that is approximately what will have to be repaid overtime. As and when the time comes, we will take a view as to how that repayment happens and it could be settled through an exchange of rupee funds based on the settlement amount. It could also be, the swaps could be rolled over if necessary and of course if market conditions permit, it can also be repaid.
Namrata Narkar, IDBI Bank: WPI inflation forecast is being placed largely between 6% and 7% for March 2014. How much of deviation from this forecast is tolerable and if the deviation is above the tolerable level, would the composition of such a deviation then hold significant?
RRR: It depends on not just the WPI, but a whole set of other measures. On the WPI we have been very clear on bringing headline below 5 and core below 3.
Prasanna, ICICI Securities: You have mentioned the negative output gap as a key factor in helping to contain inflation. Does that mean you do not expect the output gap to narrow in coming quarters and therefore you expect FY15 growth to remain around levels observed in H1FY14?
RRR: My personal sense is that with growth at let us say around 5%, we have somewhere between 1.5%-2% output gap at this point. So with that kind of situation, I think it will take a year or two to get back to potential and therefore we have some room or some time in which the output gap will continue to be negative and exert downward pressure on inflation.
Badri Niwas, Citi Bank: Given you have the experience of July, would you give some guidance to the market on whether the RBI will again use monetary policy tools as a defence for the currency in event of disruption risk that you mentioned manifesting?
RRR: There are some people who argue the disruption this time will be more limited, partly because people have already reacted somewhat over the last 3-4 months. And from India’s perspective, we are in a better position because a) our CAD is much more contained, b) our reserves have grown and we have shown an ability to raise funding if necessary and c) We have lost a fair amount in short maturity bond funds which have the ability to leave more quickly and what remains are the longer term funds.
Anjali Verma, PhillipCapital: RBI is in favour of removing gold import restrictions. Is it the right time to the remove restrictions and what adverse impact it can have on CAD.
RRR: Gold restrictions are distortion and they are a necessary distortion at this point to restore balance to the CAD. But going forward we would not like this distortion to persist and we would like to remove it.
Ashish Kela, Birla Sun Life Asset Management: Dr. Rajan had highlighted the need to provide real returns to savers. What is the plan on this front? Will this play a role in the monetary policy?
RRR: The question of providing real returns to savers is very much on our minds. We do want to restore savings growth and move towards financial savings by households and I think we have to bring inflation down to make sure that these returns are positive. In the meantime there are stop gap arrangements that are part of a longer term strategy. One example of that is inflation indexed bonds in which real returns are fixed at1.5%.
Rajeev Malik, CLSA: Given widespread macro level demand supply imbalances, what is the efficacy of a blunt instrument such as interest rate in loading CPI core inflation in the supply constrained economy?
RRR: Some of the areas where we had high inflation- pulses and milk- some of that inflation has come down considerably which means there is a supply response that is kicking in and higher prices are a way to activate that supply response. More generally, even in a situation where there are supply constraints of one kind or the other, to the extent that demand exceeds supply, it creates inflationary pressures, some of it is a necessary price adjustment or relative price adjustment, but some of it feeds into more widespread wage inflation.
Aastha Gudwani, Birla Sun Life: Are we done with the rollback of exceptional measures taken in July, is the cap on LAF here to stay? If yes, then how do you intend to reinstate repo as the permanent operative rate?
RRR: We have ample liquidity and we are largely, with a little bit of volatility, near about the repo rate as being the operational rate. So in that sense I think we have gone back to normal monetary policy at this point.
Sunday, December 8, 2013
Weekly Market Commentary - Dec 2 - Dec 6, 2013
Indian investors are a happy lot this week. Though tapering sword is still hanging over bullish investor sentiments, it seems investors have lot to rejoice over the coming days. Not just exit polls have sounded a victory for their favorite PM candidate, but it has also forced the govt. to increase the pace of their reforms as a last ditch effort to thwart the current anti-incumbency wave in the country. Govt. is back to its disinvestment ways to fill the deficit gap and is likely to make some reform announcements benefitting power and sugar industries.
Sensex gained 1.0%; Nifty gained 1.4% while CNX Midcap was up by 1.1% this week.
Monday – Sensex up by 0.5%, Nifty up by 0.7%, Midcap up by 0.7%
Markets cheered the 2QFY14 GDP growth of 4.8% vs. 4.4% in previous quarter, according to data released by govt. The growth numbers were in-line with street estimates. Also, HSBC PMI index recorded improvement in manufacturing activity for the first time since July. The Index for the manufacturing industry climbed to 51.3 in November from 49.6 in previous month.
Tuesday - Sensex down by 0.2%, Nifty down by 0.3%, Midcap flat
Markets ended up lower as investors resorted to profit booking and cautiousness ahead of Fed’s job report expected at the end of the week. Any improvement in the job recovery may lead to decision in favour of tapering of QE by Federal Reserve. Investors also stayed cautious as India’s capital, New Delhi prepares for polls next day. Even a good announcement from RBI was unable to lift the mood of the market. RBI announced that India’s current account deficit (CAD) narrowed sharply to $5.2bn or 1.2% of GDP in 2Q, from $21bn or 5% last year.
Wednesday – Sensex down by 0.7%, Nifty down by 0.7%, Midcap down by 1.0%
Market sentiments were weak as rise in crude prices added to inflationary concerns. Investors raised concerns that this may lead RBI to raise rates again raising the cost of doing business in the country.
Thursday – Sensex up by 1.2%, Nifty up by 1.3%, Midcap up by 0.8%
Markets went up and regained 21,000 levels as exit polls showed BJP coming to power in at least 4 out of 5 states that had elections recently. BJP is widely viewed as business friendly party among the host of other parties contesting the elections. Any success in state elections will be a testimony of BJP Prime Ministerial candidate Narendra Modi’s popularity and acceptance.
Friday – Sensex up by 0.2%, Nifty up by 0.3%, Midcap up by 0.5%
Exit polls results kept markets up and gave boost to the idea that congress might try to get more reform measures passed in the run up to the main elections in May 2014.
Sensex gained 1.0%; Nifty gained 1.4% while CNX Midcap was up by 1.1% this week.
Monday – Sensex up by 0.5%, Nifty up by 0.7%, Midcap up by 0.7%
Markets cheered the 2QFY14 GDP growth of 4.8% vs. 4.4% in previous quarter, according to data released by govt. The growth numbers were in-line with street estimates. Also, HSBC PMI index recorded improvement in manufacturing activity for the first time since July. The Index for the manufacturing industry climbed to 51.3 in November from 49.6 in previous month.
Tuesday - Sensex down by 0.2%, Nifty down by 0.3%, Midcap flat
Markets ended up lower as investors resorted to profit booking and cautiousness ahead of Fed’s job report expected at the end of the week. Any improvement in the job recovery may lead to decision in favour of tapering of QE by Federal Reserve. Investors also stayed cautious as India’s capital, New Delhi prepares for polls next day. Even a good announcement from RBI was unable to lift the mood of the market. RBI announced that India’s current account deficit (CAD) narrowed sharply to $5.2bn or 1.2% of GDP in 2Q, from $21bn or 5% last year.
Wednesday – Sensex down by 0.7%, Nifty down by 0.7%, Midcap down by 1.0%
Market sentiments were weak as rise in crude prices added to inflationary concerns. Investors raised concerns that this may lead RBI to raise rates again raising the cost of doing business in the country.
Thursday – Sensex up by 1.2%, Nifty up by 1.3%, Midcap up by 0.8%
Markets went up and regained 21,000 levels as exit polls showed BJP coming to power in at least 4 out of 5 states that had elections recently. BJP is widely viewed as business friendly party among the host of other parties contesting the elections. Any success in state elections will be a testimony of BJP Prime Ministerial candidate Narendra Modi’s popularity and acceptance.
Friday – Sensex up by 0.2%, Nifty up by 0.3%, Midcap up by 0.5%
Exit polls results kept markets up and gave boost to the idea that congress might try to get more reform measures passed in the run up to the main elections in May 2014.
Sunday, September 15, 2013
Weekly Market Commentary - Sept 9 - Sept 13, 2013
Receding fears of war with Syria led to cooling of oil prices that in turn led to strengthening of rupee against the global currencies. Rupee also gained strength as FIIs continued to buy Indian shares after newly appointed RBI governor Raghuram Rajan charted out plans to get the country out of its current mess. Sensex gained 2.4%, Nifty gained 3.0% and CNX Midcap was up by 3.4% this week.
Monday – Markets closed on occasion of Ganesh Chaturthi
Tuesday - Sensex up by 3.8%, Nifty up by 3.8%, Midcap up by 1.8%
Markets remained buoyant from last week sentiment boost they received from Raghuram Rajan appointment and his maiden speech as RBI governor. Global markets also took respite from the news that Russia has persuaded Syria to put its chemical weapons under international inspection, which worked to shelve the fears of US strike on Syria and led to global rally in stocks.
Telecoms were the major gainers today as TRAI reduced the base price by 37%, from Rs. 2,379cr to Rs. 1,496cr per MHz of pan India spectrum. TRAI also recommended that a flat spectrum usage (SUC) of 3% of gross revenue from 2-8% earlier. Telecom companies are expected to save around 60-80,000cr over a 20-year period.
Wednesday - Sensex up by 0.0%, Nifty up by 0.3%, Midcap up by 1.6%
Markets opened lower as some investors rushed to book profits after previous day’s rally, which was biggest gain in Sensex in four years. Market recouped its losses as day progressed as tension over Syria eased leading to cooling of oil price momentum. Also, consistent recovery in rupee is helping boost the Indian investor sentiment.
Thursday – Sensex down by 1.1%, Nifty down by 1.1%, Midcap down by 0.7%
Investors turned a little cautious and booked profits ahead of IIP and CPI inflation data release expected on Friday.
Friday – Sensex down by 0.2%, Nifty down by 0.0%, Midcap up by 0.7%
Stocks tumbled after PM’s economic panel raised its doubt over Govt. achieving its fiscal deficit target of 4.8% of GDP in current year. Investors also continued to cut positions ahead of US Fed meeting and RBI first meeting under Rajan next week. Market is keenly awaiting Fed’s decision on tapering and RBI’s response to it.
Bulls did get some respite in form of better-than-expected July 2013 IIP data (+2.6% yoy) and fall in retail inflation to 9.52% in August from 9.64% in July. August WPI data, an anchor used by RBI to decide on its policy decisions, will release on Monday.
Monday – Markets closed on occasion of Ganesh Chaturthi
Tuesday - Sensex up by 3.8%, Nifty up by 3.8%, Midcap up by 1.8%
Markets remained buoyant from last week sentiment boost they received from Raghuram Rajan appointment and his maiden speech as RBI governor. Global markets also took respite from the news that Russia has persuaded Syria to put its chemical weapons under international inspection, which worked to shelve the fears of US strike on Syria and led to global rally in stocks.
Telecoms were the major gainers today as TRAI reduced the base price by 37%, from Rs. 2,379cr to Rs. 1,496cr per MHz of pan India spectrum. TRAI also recommended that a flat spectrum usage (SUC) of 3% of gross revenue from 2-8% earlier. Telecom companies are expected to save around 60-80,000cr over a 20-year period.
Wednesday - Sensex up by 0.0%, Nifty up by 0.3%, Midcap up by 1.6%
Markets opened lower as some investors rushed to book profits after previous day’s rally, which was biggest gain in Sensex in four years. Market recouped its losses as day progressed as tension over Syria eased leading to cooling of oil price momentum. Also, consistent recovery in rupee is helping boost the Indian investor sentiment.
Thursday – Sensex down by 1.1%, Nifty down by 1.1%, Midcap down by 0.7%
Investors turned a little cautious and booked profits ahead of IIP and CPI inflation data release expected on Friday.
Friday – Sensex down by 0.2%, Nifty down by 0.0%, Midcap up by 0.7%
Stocks tumbled after PM’s economic panel raised its doubt over Govt. achieving its fiscal deficit target of 4.8% of GDP in current year. Investors also continued to cut positions ahead of US Fed meeting and RBI first meeting under Rajan next week. Market is keenly awaiting Fed’s decision on tapering and RBI’s response to it.
Bulls did get some respite in form of better-than-expected July 2013 IIP data (+2.6% yoy) and fall in retail inflation to 9.52% in August from 9.64% in July. August WPI data, an anchor used by RBI to decide on its policy decisions, will release on Monday.
Friday, August 30, 2013
Weekly Market Commentary - Aug 23 - Aug 30, 2013
This week witnessed the most productive parliament in recent history (pardon the oxymoron) where Govt was able to pass two landmark bills viz. Food Security Bill and Land Acquisition Bill. While the jury is still out on whether these bills will be able to help the poor and farmers of the nation or are simple vote fetching attempts of ruling party and will forever drown our poor under behemoth of Indian bureaucracy and corruption, we can be sure of one thing: Rising cost of living.
Sensex gained a little 0.5%, Nifty was flat and Midcap lost 0.8% this week.
Monday - Sensex up by 0.2%, Nifty up by 0.1%, Midcap up by 0.7%
Markets went up as FM tried to convince investors to expect some good decisions in next one week to attract capital flows to finance our rising current account deficit. In addition, a slump in US home sales allayed the fears of tapering in Fed stimulus spending which boosted the investor sentiment.
Tuesday - Sensex down by 3.2%, Nifty down by 3.5%, Midcap down by 2.4%
Mayhem in the markets as Govt was successful in passing Food Security Bill in Lok Sabha (Lower House of the Parliament). Food subsidy is now expected to cost around 1% of GDP to the exchequer, according to Govt calculations but analysts estimates it to be 3% of the GDP. See my recent post on subsidy bill calculation here. Rupee made all-time low of 68.80 against the dollar as FIIs scrambled for exit.
Wednesday - Sensex up by 0.2%, Nifty flat, Midcap down by 1.1%
Markets recovered a bit from yesterday’s crash as investors hunt for bargains in IT, Capital Goods and Healthcare sector. India’s largest insurer Life Insurance Corporation of India did some buying and provided support to the falling indices. Stocks remained under pressure as sabre rattling in Syria sent the crude price higher and rise in credit risks across the emerging markets.
Thursday - Sensex up by 2.2%, Nifty up by 2.3%, Midcap up by 1.5%
Benchmark index rose dramatically as investors cover their shorts on the last Thursday of the month. Also, RBI’s move to start a forex swap facility to help PSU oil companies meet their daily dollar demand provided support to rupee which gained by 2.5% against the dollar.
Friday - Sensex up by 1.2%, Nifty up by 1.2%, Midcap up by 0.6%
Markets continued their previous day’s upside momentum as Prime Minister Manmohan Singh clearly stated in his speech in parliament that he will take all measures to fight country’s deficit without bringing in capital controls and reversal of reforms. He also made clear that his Govt is going ahead with reforms including subsidy reduction and implementation of GST.
Sensex gained a little 0.5%, Nifty was flat and Midcap lost 0.8% this week.
Monday - Sensex up by 0.2%, Nifty up by 0.1%, Midcap up by 0.7%
Markets went up as FM tried to convince investors to expect some good decisions in next one week to attract capital flows to finance our rising current account deficit. In addition, a slump in US home sales allayed the fears of tapering in Fed stimulus spending which boosted the investor sentiment.
Tuesday - Sensex down by 3.2%, Nifty down by 3.5%, Midcap down by 2.4%
Mayhem in the markets as Govt was successful in passing Food Security Bill in Lok Sabha (Lower House of the Parliament). Food subsidy is now expected to cost around 1% of GDP to the exchequer, according to Govt calculations but analysts estimates it to be 3% of the GDP. See my recent post on subsidy bill calculation here. Rupee made all-time low of 68.80 against the dollar as FIIs scrambled for exit.
Wednesday - Sensex up by 0.2%, Nifty flat, Midcap down by 1.1%
Markets recovered a bit from yesterday’s crash as investors hunt for bargains in IT, Capital Goods and Healthcare sector. India’s largest insurer Life Insurance Corporation of India did some buying and provided support to the falling indices. Stocks remained under pressure as sabre rattling in Syria sent the crude price higher and rise in credit risks across the emerging markets.
Thursday - Sensex up by 2.2%, Nifty up by 2.3%, Midcap up by 1.5%
Benchmark index rose dramatically as investors cover their shorts on the last Thursday of the month. Also, RBI’s move to start a forex swap facility to help PSU oil companies meet their daily dollar demand provided support to rupee which gained by 2.5% against the dollar.
Friday - Sensex up by 1.2%, Nifty up by 1.2%, Midcap up by 0.6%
Markets continued their previous day’s upside momentum as Prime Minister Manmohan Singh clearly stated in his speech in parliament that he will take all measures to fight country’s deficit without bringing in capital controls and reversal of reforms. He also made clear that his Govt is going ahead with reforms including subsidy reduction and implementation of GST.
Tuesday, August 27, 2013
Have We Bitten More Than We Can Chew...
Reminder to our readers how much impact (read damage) newly proposed Food Security Bill can cause country’s balance sheet.
Hat tip to Surjit Bhalla for brilliant analysis in which he clearly shows Food Security Bill to be costing as much as 3% of India’s GDP, almost equal to total education spending. Read the article here.
Hat tip to Surjit Bhalla for brilliant analysis in which he clearly shows Food Security Bill to be costing as much as 3% of India’s GDP, almost equal to total education spending. Read the article here.
Sunday, August 4, 2013
RBI Analyst Conference Call Summary
Headline
RBI kept all the policy rates unchanged; the repo rate, the reverse repo rate and the CRR. The MSF rate too stayed at 10.25% with a mark-up of 300 basis points above the repo rate.
Two key things on RBI's mind while drafting this policy: external sector concerns, especially those stemming from global financial markets over the last 10 weeks (read Fed stimulus tapering plans); the second was the standard concern of any central bank of maintaining growth and inflation balance.
On Growth
On the domestic front, the silver lining is that the monsoon so far has been above long term average. However, industrial production is lower than what RBI thought it was and services sector activity is subdued in part because of because of tepid global demand.
Keeping all this mind, RBI revised its FY14 GDP growth projections downwards from 5.7% to 5.5%.
On Inflation
The biggest risk to inflation is from the depreciation of the rupee and the any pass-through from there. RBI’s recent study shows that the coefficient of pass-through has increased and now every 10% depreciation results in a 1.2% increase in inflation vs. 1.1% earlier.
Vulnerabilities
RBI discussed four risk factors in which biggest is vulnerability in the external sector, in particular sudden stop and reversal of capital flows seen over the last 10 weeks.
The second risk factor is the large CAD, which has stayed above the sustainable level for 3 years in a row and has affected external payment situation. Most external vulnerability indicators have deteriorated indicating that the economy’s resilience to external shocks is eroded.
The third risk factor is the continuing weak investment environment which remains weak because of a number of factors such as cost and time overruns, high leverage, deteriorating cash flows, erosion of asset quality and muted credit confidence.
The final risk factor is something that has sort of stuck, which is the supply constraints in the economy. There are a number of supply constraints especially in the food and infrastructure sectors which affect growth and inflation.
Guidance
RBI is caught in a classic ‘impossible trinity’ trilemma (more about it here). It has to forfeit economy’s growth inflation dynamic, informed monetary policy stance, in order to take care of external concerns.
RBI will roll back liquidity-tightening measures in a calibrated manner as forex markets stabilizes.
Q&A
Kaushik Das (DB): Hi, my question is regarding India’s reserve adequacy. As per the latest data, reserves can still cover about 6-7-months of imports but particularly worrying is the sharp increase in the short-term external debt on a residual maturity basis, which has touched $172 billion odd. So how concerned is RBI about this reserve adequacy position of India, especially when reserves are down further due to FX intervention?
The second question is regarding the potential growth rate of economy. Last year the expectation was that the potential growth rate has come down to about 6.5 to 7%. Does RBI think that the potential growth rate has fallen further in the wake of the developments of the last few months?
Dr. Urjit Patel (Dy. Guv): We actually feel that our reserves are adequate; 6.5 to 7-month of import cover is good, our short-term debt has increased but the short-term debt has been comfortably rolled over and refinanced over the last 3 years despite the high CAD. Even IMF, by the criteria they use, feels that our reserve position is adequate and comfortable.
On the potential growth, the RBI’s calculations and models suggest that it is about 7% now.
Sonal Varma (Nomura): I wanted to ask what is the risk that these tightening measures can precipitate into a bigger problem for the banking system, because of asset quality stress. What is the RBI’s view on that?
Dr. K. C. Chakrabarty: Anyhow, RBI will not be able to protect banks’ asset quality. Suppose, if you allow the exchange rate to depreciate, then the corporates, who have gone for ECB borrowings will default and banks asset quality will deteriorate. And if the rate has gone up then definitely because of the portfolio depreciation, they will be affected. We feel that HTM is more manageable because banks must understand the risk and we allow lot of amount to be put in the HTM category so this is a better option, which is our assessment.
Simon Flint (Dymon Asia Capital): Governor, you suggested that because of the large current account deficit, the rupee depreciation in some senses would be warranted. On the other hand, you do have some economists, I think including some in the Ministry of Finance who have argued that if you compare the present value of the rupee to the real effective exchange rate (REER), let us say which prevailed over 2004-2005, then the rupee is actually overshooting and is now undervalued. So I guess can you give us a sense of where you see rupee today relative to its fair value.
Dr. D. Subbarao: My answer to your very well argued question is quite short, that the RBI does not take a position on the level of the exchange rate. The depreciation of the currency has costs for the economy, but that is a different matter. We do not take a position on the exchange rate; there are various ways of calculating it including the way that you have indicated from the Ministry of Finance. All we said yesterday was that because of the current account deficit, the rupee would have depreciated and that has not happened because we have been able to finance it, and now that there is capital flow issues, those strains are coming into play, and the rupee is depreciating.
Rajeev Malik (CLSA): RBI has consistently maintained that it does not target any particular level and it is really only concerned with the volatility. The government on the other hand, every time the rupee slips, begins to get palpitations partly although not entirely, because of the impact on the fiscal front. How do you marry the two? At the end of the day a lot of that worsening because of rupee depreciation also has a feedback loop into how monetary policy is being conducted.
Dr. D. Subbarao: Both the government and the RBI are really on the same page as far as larger objective is concerned which is to control volatility. Neither the government nor the Reserve Bank is targeting any particular rate. And that is the message I think everybody listening in must take away.
RBI kept all the policy rates unchanged; the repo rate, the reverse repo rate and the CRR. The MSF rate too stayed at 10.25% with a mark-up of 300 basis points above the repo rate.
Two key things on RBI's mind while drafting this policy: external sector concerns, especially those stemming from global financial markets over the last 10 weeks (read Fed stimulus tapering plans); the second was the standard concern of any central bank of maintaining growth and inflation balance.
On Growth
On the domestic front, the silver lining is that the monsoon so far has been above long term average. However, industrial production is lower than what RBI thought it was and services sector activity is subdued in part because of because of tepid global demand.
Keeping all this mind, RBI revised its FY14 GDP growth projections downwards from 5.7% to 5.5%.
On Inflation
The biggest risk to inflation is from the depreciation of the rupee and the any pass-through from there. RBI’s recent study shows that the coefficient of pass-through has increased and now every 10% depreciation results in a 1.2% increase in inflation vs. 1.1% earlier.
Vulnerabilities
RBI discussed four risk factors in which biggest is vulnerability in the external sector, in particular sudden stop and reversal of capital flows seen over the last 10 weeks.
The second risk factor is the large CAD, which has stayed above the sustainable level for 3 years in a row and has affected external payment situation. Most external vulnerability indicators have deteriorated indicating that the economy’s resilience to external shocks is eroded.
The third risk factor is the continuing weak investment environment which remains weak because of a number of factors such as cost and time overruns, high leverage, deteriorating cash flows, erosion of asset quality and muted credit confidence.
The final risk factor is something that has sort of stuck, which is the supply constraints in the economy. There are a number of supply constraints especially in the food and infrastructure sectors which affect growth and inflation.
Guidance
RBI is caught in a classic ‘impossible trinity’ trilemma (more about it here). It has to forfeit economy’s growth inflation dynamic, informed monetary policy stance, in order to take care of external concerns.
RBI will roll back liquidity-tightening measures in a calibrated manner as forex markets stabilizes.
Q&A
Kaushik Das (DB): Hi, my question is regarding India’s reserve adequacy. As per the latest data, reserves can still cover about 6-7-months of imports but particularly worrying is the sharp increase in the short-term external debt on a residual maturity basis, which has touched $172 billion odd. So how concerned is RBI about this reserve adequacy position of India, especially when reserves are down further due to FX intervention?
The second question is regarding the potential growth rate of economy. Last year the expectation was that the potential growth rate has come down to about 6.5 to 7%. Does RBI think that the potential growth rate has fallen further in the wake of the developments of the last few months?
Dr. Urjit Patel (Dy. Guv): We actually feel that our reserves are adequate; 6.5 to 7-month of import cover is good, our short-term debt has increased but the short-term debt has been comfortably rolled over and refinanced over the last 3 years despite the high CAD. Even IMF, by the criteria they use, feels that our reserve position is adequate and comfortable.
On the potential growth, the RBI’s calculations and models suggest that it is about 7% now.
Sonal Varma (Nomura): I wanted to ask what is the risk that these tightening measures can precipitate into a bigger problem for the banking system, because of asset quality stress. What is the RBI’s view on that?
Dr. K. C. Chakrabarty: Anyhow, RBI will not be able to protect banks’ asset quality. Suppose, if you allow the exchange rate to depreciate, then the corporates, who have gone for ECB borrowings will default and banks asset quality will deteriorate. And if the rate has gone up then definitely because of the portfolio depreciation, they will be affected. We feel that HTM is more manageable because banks must understand the risk and we allow lot of amount to be put in the HTM category so this is a better option, which is our assessment.
Simon Flint (Dymon Asia Capital): Governor, you suggested that because of the large current account deficit, the rupee depreciation in some senses would be warranted. On the other hand, you do have some economists, I think including some in the Ministry of Finance who have argued that if you compare the present value of the rupee to the real effective exchange rate (REER), let us say which prevailed over 2004-2005, then the rupee is actually overshooting and is now undervalued. So I guess can you give us a sense of where you see rupee today relative to its fair value.
Dr. D. Subbarao: My answer to your very well argued question is quite short, that the RBI does not take a position on the level of the exchange rate. The depreciation of the currency has costs for the economy, but that is a different matter. We do not take a position on the exchange rate; there are various ways of calculating it including the way that you have indicated from the Ministry of Finance. All we said yesterday was that because of the current account deficit, the rupee would have depreciated and that has not happened because we have been able to finance it, and now that there is capital flow issues, those strains are coming into play, and the rupee is depreciating.
Rajeev Malik (CLSA): RBI has consistently maintained that it does not target any particular level and it is really only concerned with the volatility. The government on the other hand, every time the rupee slips, begins to get palpitations partly although not entirely, because of the impact on the fiscal front. How do you marry the two? At the end of the day a lot of that worsening because of rupee depreciation also has a feedback loop into how monetary policy is being conducted.
Dr. D. Subbarao: Both the government and the RBI are really on the same page as far as larger objective is concerned which is to control volatility. Neither the government nor the Reserve Bank is targeting any particular rate. And that is the message I think everybody listening in must take away.
Saturday, August 3, 2013
Weekly Market Commentary - Jul 29 - Aug 2, 2013
Markets continued to weigh down by RBI policy actions, which have raised the cost of doing business on the country. Banks, realty, metals, all rates sensitive stocks, were badly hit this week. RBI’s battle against the falling rupee has been futile as currency is back at 61 against the dollar. Sensex was down 3%, Nifty was down 3.5% and CNX Midcap 5.9% this week.
Monday - Sensex down by 0.8%, Nifty down by 0.9%, Midcap down by 1.3%
Markets continued their downward trend with investors acing cautious ahead of RBI meeting on Tuesday. RBI has tightened liquidity environment in a bid to save rupee from falling further. Many investors are nervous wondering whether RBI will continue its stance and increase the rates to make rupee investment attractive for FIIs, as SBI chairman suggested. Investors are also anticipating announcement related to sovereign debt offering country might plan to plug the deficit gap.
Tuesday - Sensex down by 1.3%, Nifty down by 1.3%, Midcap down by 2.4%
In its policy announcement, RBI kept all key rates unchanged (repo rate at 7.25%, CRR at 4%), but revised the country’s GDP growth projection for FY14 downwards from 5.5% to 5.7%. RBI also indicated its reservation about issuing of sovereign debt, calling the timing now not right. Markets plunged after the policy announcement and rupee tumbled down to 61 mark.
Wednesday - Sensex down by 0.0%, Nifty down by 0.2%, Midcap up by 0.2%
Sensex ended up flat after falling almost 220 points in its initial sessions. FM who indicated more liberalization policies are under consideration and encouraged PSUs to borrow from abroad saved the markets. Govt is also considering raising import duty on non-essential luxury items to contain CAD.
Bharti Airtel was among the top gainer, with the company showing growth signs in its ARPUs, which increased, to INR200 for 1Q14, +16 y-o-y, EBITDA margin increased to 32.3% from 29.6% a year back.
Thursday - Sensex down by 0.1%, Nifty down by 0.2%, Midcap down by 1.4%
Indian markets rallied during their early sessions with their Asian peers as China reported better than expected PMI data while US GDP growth also beating street estimates. However, later in the day, weaker manufacturing data put the brakes on the rally and drag down the markets back in the red zone.
Financial Technologies, promoter of MCX, leading commodity exchange of the country, tanked by 65% today as govt asked its National Spot Exchange to not to launch new products, following with firm (NSEL) decided to suspend trading and postponed settlement of all 1 day forward contracts.
Friday - Sensex down by 0.8%, Nifty down by 0.9%, Midcap down by 1.1%
Markets saw heavy selling across metals, power, realty and PSUs as concerns over rise in cost of operations in tight monetary environment has made investors bearish over these counters.
Financial Technologies fell another 23% as crisis over National Spot Exchange has dealt to commodity investors sentiments. Power Grid Corp fell 11% after firm announced plans to dilute equity to fund its investment plans.
Monday - Sensex down by 0.8%, Nifty down by 0.9%, Midcap down by 1.3%
Markets continued their downward trend with investors acing cautious ahead of RBI meeting on Tuesday. RBI has tightened liquidity environment in a bid to save rupee from falling further. Many investors are nervous wondering whether RBI will continue its stance and increase the rates to make rupee investment attractive for FIIs, as SBI chairman suggested. Investors are also anticipating announcement related to sovereign debt offering country might plan to plug the deficit gap.
Tuesday - Sensex down by 1.3%, Nifty down by 1.3%, Midcap down by 2.4%
In its policy announcement, RBI kept all key rates unchanged (repo rate at 7.25%, CRR at 4%), but revised the country’s GDP growth projection for FY14 downwards from 5.5% to 5.7%. RBI also indicated its reservation about issuing of sovereign debt, calling the timing now not right. Markets plunged after the policy announcement and rupee tumbled down to 61 mark.
Wednesday - Sensex down by 0.0%, Nifty down by 0.2%, Midcap up by 0.2%
Sensex ended up flat after falling almost 220 points in its initial sessions. FM who indicated more liberalization policies are under consideration and encouraged PSUs to borrow from abroad saved the markets. Govt is also considering raising import duty on non-essential luxury items to contain CAD.
Bharti Airtel was among the top gainer, with the company showing growth signs in its ARPUs, which increased, to INR200 for 1Q14, +16 y-o-y, EBITDA margin increased to 32.3% from 29.6% a year back.
Thursday - Sensex down by 0.1%, Nifty down by 0.2%, Midcap down by 1.4%
Indian markets rallied during their early sessions with their Asian peers as China reported better than expected PMI data while US GDP growth also beating street estimates. However, later in the day, weaker manufacturing data put the brakes on the rally and drag down the markets back in the red zone.
Financial Technologies, promoter of MCX, leading commodity exchange of the country, tanked by 65% today as govt asked its National Spot Exchange to not to launch new products, following with firm (NSEL) decided to suspend trading and postponed settlement of all 1 day forward contracts.
Friday - Sensex down by 0.8%, Nifty down by 0.9%, Midcap down by 1.1%
Markets saw heavy selling across metals, power, realty and PSUs as concerns over rise in cost of operations in tight monetary environment has made investors bearish over these counters.
Financial Technologies fell another 23% as crisis over National Spot Exchange has dealt to commodity investors sentiments. Power Grid Corp fell 11% after firm announced plans to dilute equity to fund its investment plans.
Saturday, June 29, 2013
Weekly Market Commentary - Jun 24 - Jun 28, 2013
Monday - Sensex down by 1.2%, Nifty down by 1.4%, Midcap down by 2.6%
Market extended their losses from previous week as the global stocks continue to slid post Fed announcement of curtailing its bond buying program. Market seems to be ignoring the ifs and buts in the announcement and is running havoc with no plan in sight. Markets were also nervous when Chinese central bank made comments to the effect that liquidity in the system is reasonable, when China is facing liquidity squeeze. Central bank suggested fine tuning the system, which market assumed as reducing liquidity. Shanghai went down more than 5%.
Indian markets mirroring their global peers, are also under pressure due to rising CAD worries and fall in currency value. Brokers are of the view that FIIs have sold over $5 billion of debt and equities in June so far.
Tuesday - Sensex up by 0.5%, Nifty up by 0.3%, Midcap down by 0.6%
The Indian stocks went up in early trade as China tries to soothe investors’ nerves, short covering as F&O expiry nears. Markets also bought oil and gas stocks ahead of pending decision on gas price revision. Gas price were supposed to be revised previous week itself but the decision was deferred as Oil Minister was out for an official tour.
Wednesday - Sensex down by 0.4%, Nifty down by 0.4%, Midcap down by 0.0%
The Chinese central bank move to provide liquidity to some parts of its financial system to stabilize money market rates cheered the global market. Indian markets had a rangebound session as good news from China, short covering due to nearing F&O expiry was completely offset by rupee playing a spoilsport sliding below 60/$ level.
Thursday - Sensex up by 1.7%, Nifty up by 1.7%, Midcap up by 0.7%
Sensex and Nifty rallied as investors cheered the downward revision on US GDP data from 2.4% to 1.8%, which eased the concerns of reduced Fed spending. RBI also took advantage of this news and advanced its release of CAD data by one day. India's March quarter CAD came at $18.1 billion, 3.6% of GDP vs. consensus estimate of $21.7 billion or 4.4% of GDP. Corresponding figure for December quarter was 6.7%. The FY13 CAD stood at $88.2 billion and the Q4 Balance of Payments (BoP) stood at a surplus of $300 billion versus a $600 billion deficit year-on-year. Short coverings on the last expiry day of June series also buoyed the market.
Friday - Sensex up by 2.8%, Nifty up by 2.8%, Midcap up by 2.9%
Indian markets rallied as govt got its act together and approved doubling of gas prices from current $4.2/mmbtu to $8.4/mmbtu. The gas price decision was in limbo for several months now as various govt ministries, such as fertilizer, power and oil quarrel over the impact on their respective sectors. This decision was in tandem with the recent approval to power producers to pass on the imported coal cost to the consumers. The new gas pricing will get into force from April 1, 2014 and will work to attract investments in the sector as it makes several projects, big or small, across the country even more economical.
Rupee also rebounded to 59 levels after govt announced reforms to attract investments in the country and reduce country's dependence on imported gas (fuel). Govt has also initiated towards setting up of a coal regulator to settle disputed over quality and quantity of coal sold in the Indian markets. The poor quality of coal has led to squabbling between the country's premier energy producer NTPC and largest coal producer Coal India.
Friday, May 31, 2013
Weekly Market Commentary - May 27 - May 31, 2013
We started the week with big bang news of another potentially huge discovery in KG-D6 by RIL and ended the week with weak, but expected sub 5% 4Q GDP numbers.
In the context of current Indian market performance, you can safely say that current volatility is the by-product of easy liquidity and uncertain economic environment. Every new economic data brings with it the question everyone is asking, whether this is the last of the bad news we are receiving. With every data release, we hear experts talking about Indian market bottoming out. But have we?
Current GDP figures are at decade low, consumption is showing decline, rupee is falling, RBI is dithering on rate cuts and Indian investor is choosing to stay away from stocks making our markets even more vulnerable to sudden FII outflow which could prove disastrous to the economy. This week sensex made a small gain of 0.3% while Nifty and CNX Midcap ended flat.
Monday - Sensex up by 1.7%, Nifty up by 1.7%, Midcap up by 1.2%
Sensex zoomed past 20K mark, gaining more than 350 points in the process. Main catalyst was Reliance Industries late Friday announcement of big gas discovery in KG D6 basin. Company is planning to start appraisal drilling soon to ascertain the amount of gas discovered. It remains to be seen how much of this gas, Reliance, can actually drill out commercially. Discovery also gives Reliance an additional weapon to strongly pursue market pricing of gas with govt. RIL, along with its partner BP are currently negotiating for higher price for their KG-D6 gas which is strongly contested by Petroleum Ministry and Fertilizer Ministry. There was also some short covering seen in the market, as current F&O contract expires this week.
Tuesday - Sensex up by 0.6%, Nifty up by 0.5%, Midcap up by 0.6%
Markets remained cautious ahead of GDP data announcement on Friday. Coal India, country's largest coal supplier, which reported earnings post market hours previous day, reported a jump of 35%, beating the consensus estimates, on the back of higher supplies and lower employee expenses. Company also announced its decision to hike prices by 10%.
Wednesday - Sensex down by 0.1%, Nifty down by 0.1%, Midcap down by 0.6%
No major movements in Sensex, as markets focus on Friday GDP data announcement and F&O expiry. Sun Pharma, country's top drugmaker by market value, reported 23% rise in 4Q profits and announced a bonus share issue.
Thursday - Sensex up by 0.3%, Nifty up by 0.3%, Midcap down by 0.1%
Sensex made small gain as investors cover up their position on the day of F&O expiry. Tata Motors and Mahindra & Mahindra beat the consensus estimates while ONGC reported a decline in 4Q profit on the back of lower sales and higher payment on statutory levies.
Friday - Sensex down by 2.3%, Nifty down by 2.3%, Midcap down by 1.0%
Markets went downhill as GDP grew at mere 4.8% in 4Q and 5% for full fiscal year 2013. Though, the street was expecting sub 5% GDP figure for 4Q, it was the comments from RBI which set the bearish tone pushing the investors towards the exit. RBI governor maintained it cautious stance suggesting that inflation data still has upward risk while current account position stays out of comfortable range. These comments deprived the market of any rate cut hopes in June meeting and led to selling across the board. Rupee also took the hit and is trading now at close proximity of 57 to a dollar.
In the context of current Indian market performance, you can safely say that current volatility is the by-product of easy liquidity and uncertain economic environment. Every new economic data brings with it the question everyone is asking, whether this is the last of the bad news we are receiving. With every data release, we hear experts talking about Indian market bottoming out. But have we?
Current GDP figures are at decade low, consumption is showing decline, rupee is falling, RBI is dithering on rate cuts and Indian investor is choosing to stay away from stocks making our markets even more vulnerable to sudden FII outflow which could prove disastrous to the economy. This week sensex made a small gain of 0.3% while Nifty and CNX Midcap ended flat.
Monday - Sensex up by 1.7%, Nifty up by 1.7%, Midcap up by 1.2%
Sensex zoomed past 20K mark, gaining more than 350 points in the process. Main catalyst was Reliance Industries late Friday announcement of big gas discovery in KG D6 basin. Company is planning to start appraisal drilling soon to ascertain the amount of gas discovered. It remains to be seen how much of this gas, Reliance, can actually drill out commercially. Discovery also gives Reliance an additional weapon to strongly pursue market pricing of gas with govt. RIL, along with its partner BP are currently negotiating for higher price for their KG-D6 gas which is strongly contested by Petroleum Ministry and Fertilizer Ministry. There was also some short covering seen in the market, as current F&O contract expires this week.
Tuesday - Sensex up by 0.6%, Nifty up by 0.5%, Midcap up by 0.6%
Markets remained cautious ahead of GDP data announcement on Friday. Coal India, country's largest coal supplier, which reported earnings post market hours previous day, reported a jump of 35%, beating the consensus estimates, on the back of higher supplies and lower employee expenses. Company also announced its decision to hike prices by 10%.
Wednesday - Sensex down by 0.1%, Nifty down by 0.1%, Midcap down by 0.6%
No major movements in Sensex, as markets focus on Friday GDP data announcement and F&O expiry. Sun Pharma, country's top drugmaker by market value, reported 23% rise in 4Q profits and announced a bonus share issue.
Thursday - Sensex up by 0.3%, Nifty up by 0.3%, Midcap down by 0.1%
Sensex made small gain as investors cover up their position on the day of F&O expiry. Tata Motors and Mahindra & Mahindra beat the consensus estimates while ONGC reported a decline in 4Q profit on the back of lower sales and higher payment on statutory levies.
Friday - Sensex down by 2.3%, Nifty down by 2.3%, Midcap down by 1.0%
Markets went downhill as GDP grew at mere 4.8% in 4Q and 5% for full fiscal year 2013. Though, the street was expecting sub 5% GDP figure for 4Q, it was the comments from RBI which set the bearish tone pushing the investors towards the exit. RBI governor maintained it cautious stance suggesting that inflation data still has upward risk while current account position stays out of comfortable range. These comments deprived the market of any rate cut hopes in June meeting and led to selling across the board. Rupee also took the hit and is trading now at close proximity of 57 to a dollar.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)